(no subject)

[randomness]

Nate Silver, on a recent Brookings Institution transit study:

I want to point out that just because a study uses objective criteria, that doesn’t make it sensible. In fact, studies that try to rank or rate things seem especially susceptible to slapdash, unthoughtful methodology (here is another example: a study which concludes that Gainesville, Fla., is a more gay-friendly city than San Francisco). If you come up with a result that defies common sense — like Modesto’s having better public transit than New York — then once in a blue moon, you may be on to something: conventional wisdom is fallible. But much, much more often, it’s a sign that you’ve done something wrong, and it’s time to reconsider your assumptions before publishing.

Comments

[achinhibitor.livejournal.com]

Of course more jobs and people are within mass-transit range in Modesto -- it has a higher percentage of illegals (who aren't allowed driver's licenses), so housing and employers can't move away from bus lines.