![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
randomness...but how does this differ from sports gambling, exactly?
Red Sox Reward Futures Traders Who Favored Them Over Yankees
"The Boston Red Sox, who became the first team in Major League Baseball history to win a playoff series after trailing three games to none, rewarded the futures traders who made them favorites against the New York Yankees.
"The payoff was even greater for speculators who wagered on the Red Sox when their futures contracts were selling for pennies on the dollar.
"Traders were paying more for Boston contracts than for New York futures before the American League Championship Series, even though the Red Sox haven't won baseball's title since 1918, and the Yankees have won four of the past eight.
"``It's phenomenal how efficient the sports markets are,'' said Mike Knesevitch, a spokesman for TradeSports.com, an online exchange where futures contracts were traded on the series. ``I'm always amazed.''
"Traders on the Dublin, Ireland-based exchange who were betting on a Red Sox victory were able to redeem contracts that were almost worthless four days earlier. Traders were able to increase their investments 40-fold if they bought Boston contracts at their low and held them until today."
http://quote.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000103&sid=aMJUmSbh.O8o&refer=us
Red Sox Reward Futures Traders Who Favored Them Over Yankees
"The Boston Red Sox, who became the first team in Major League Baseball history to win a playoff series after trailing three games to none, rewarded the futures traders who made them favorites against the New York Yankees.
"The payoff was even greater for speculators who wagered on the Red Sox when their futures contracts were selling for pennies on the dollar.
"Traders were paying more for Boston contracts than for New York futures before the American League Championship Series, even though the Red Sox haven't won baseball's title since 1918, and the Yankees have won four of the past eight.
"``It's phenomenal how efficient the sports markets are,'' said Mike Knesevitch, a spokesman for TradeSports.com, an online exchange where futures contracts were traded on the series. ``I'm always amazed.''
"Traders on the Dublin, Ireland-based exchange who were betting on a Red Sox victory were able to redeem contracts that were almost worthless four days earlier. Traders were able to increase their investments 40-fold if they bought Boston contracts at their low and held them until today."
http://quote.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000103&sid=aMJUmSbh.O8o&refer=us
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2004-10-21 12:59 pm (UTC)Sure, and by rights either market pressure should force Ladbrokes and other bookmaking services to lower their spreads, or face going out of business.
I think you're focusing on something I agree with you about: that we should encourage transparency and efficiency of markets. My question is why there are legal sanctions against gambling and why when you call it investment, or even speculation, it's suddenly ennobled by this renaming and those legal sanctions vanish, even when fundamentally the activity is the same.
It's a social question, really, and one which I find intriguing.
(no subject)
Date: 2004-10-21 01:11 pm (UTC)1) Tradesports is by no means legal in the US; at best it's dark grey.
2) Stock market investing for some people, and in some situations, is just a way for people to risk money in order to make more, but the stock market serves many many other intrinsically valuable purposes with regards to how our economic system fundamentally works. The gambling part of it is integral to how it works, but not so integral to its goals.
(no subject)
Date: 2004-10-21 01:31 pm (UTC)Tradesports is by no means legal in the US; at best it's dark grey.
While Tradesports is dark grey, the Iowa Electronic Markets seem a lot less grey.
the stock market serves many many other intrinsically valuable purposes
From http://www.biz.uiowa.edu/iem/about/:
"The Iowa Electronic Markets are operated by faculty at the University of Iowa Henry B. Tippie College of Business as part of our research and teaching mission...
"We, and many of our colleagues at other institutions, use the markets in classes as a pedagogical tool. We have found them to be an excellent way to focus attention and give hands-on experience with real-world markets.
"As a research tool, the markets provide us with an unparalleled laboratory in which we can study individual trading behavior as well as market level performance.
"The quality of our data is improved by interested traders participating in the markets."
So, if I generalize correctly, the argument is: "We're not gambling for the sake of gambling. The gambling is essential to our operation, but isn't the intrinsic purpose of what we're doing. Therefore, it's okay."
It does seem that if the Iowa Electronic Markets were doing millions of dollars worth of trading every day, they might start rethinking things.
By this measure, Tradesports.com is in a much darker grey area.
Thanks! This is helpful.